Joe Hill’s First Reagan Sunday Supper | Blue Bloods (Tom Selleck, Will Hochman, Donny Wahlberg)
Movie Spoiler for “Bloodline Oath”
The film opens on a quiet Sunday evening in New York City. The camera pans over the skyline before settling on a familiar sight — the Reagan family brownstone, where generations of cops have gathered every week for family dinner. The table is set, candles flicker softly, and the aroma of home-cooked roast fills the air.
At the head of the table sits Frank Reagan, the city’s Police Commissioner — stern, dignified, but weary. Around him are the familiar faces of his family: Danny, the seasoned detective with a temper and a heart of gold; Erin, the sharp-minded prosecutor whose moral compass never wavers; Jamie, the youngest son who wears both his badge and his ideals with quiet pride; and Eddie, Jamie’s devoted wife and partner on the force.
Laughter hums through the room, but the atmosphere changes when the doorbell rings.
“Sorry I’m late,” Jamie calls from the hall. “We have… company.”
The family turns. Behind him stands a stranger — tall, with a polite smile and eyes that carry something familiar.
“Everyone, this is my cousin Joe,” Jamie says.
The table falls silent. The name Joe hangs heavy in the air — a name they haven’t spoken easily in years. Joe Reagan, the eldest brother, was killed in the line of duty over a decade ago.
Frank’s hand tightens around his glass. “Come again?”
The young man nods. “I’m Joe — Joe Hill. My father was Joe Reagan.”
A stunned beat passes before anyone speaks. Then Danny, half in disbelief, half in awe, breaks the silence. “I heard about you,” he says. “Didn’t think I’d ever actually meet you.”
The young man smiles. “Trust me, neither did I.”

Introductions ripple around the room. “I’m Jamie,” says the youngest Reagan. “And this is my wife, Eddie.”
Eddie steps forward, extending her hand warmly. “Great to meet you, Joe.”
He shakes it gently. “Hey, Eddie.”
Then Erin rises, smiling softly. “I’m Erin — your aunt, I suppose.”
Joe laughs lightly. “Nice to meet you, Aunt Erin. I heard you’re the only Reagan who didn’t end up a cop.”
She chuckles. “That’s right. I’m the smart one.”
Laughter breaks the tension. Even Frank allows a smile to flicker across his face.
Danny leans back, nodding approvingly. “He’s a Reagan all right.”
For a moment, the mood softens. It feels like the family has found something — or someone — they didn’t know they were missing.
Frank finally stands, crossing the room. “Joe,” he says, voice calm but full of emotion, “welcome home.”
“Thank you, sir,” Joe replies instinctively.
Frank pauses, raising an eyebrow. “You can call me whatever you want — just not sir.”
Joe grins. “Yes… Commissioner.”
The family laughs again, the tension dissolving into warmth.
Dinner begins, and the clatter of plates and chatter fills the air. The conversation flows easily — police stories, court cases, old memories. For the first time, Joe feels like he belongs.
Halfway through the meal, Frank looks around the table, eyes softening. “You know,” he says quietly, “your father sat right there every Sunday. Same spot you’re in now.”
Joe looks down at his plate, overwhelmed. “Feels right,” he says.
Danny raises his glass. “To family — the ones we lost and the ones we just found.”
Everyone joins in. “To family.”
They clink glasses, and for a brief, shining moment, everything feels whole.
But beneath the laughter, shadows stir. Joe’s arrival isn’t just a family reunion — it’s the start of something bigger. Unknown to the rest of the Reagans, Joe Hill has been working undercover within the ATF, investigating a gun-running ring tied to a series of police corruption cases. His last assignment brought him face to face with names that shouldn’t have been on those files — names connected to the NYPD itself.
As they eat, Joe’s phone vibrates silently in his pocket. A single message flashes across the screen: “You’re being watched.”
He slips the phone away, forcing a smile when Jamie asks him about work. “I’m in federal enforcement,” Joe says vaguely. “It’s complicated.”
“Everything in this family is,” Danny jokes.
Later, when the laughter dies down, Frank signals to Jamie to say grace. “Sean, you started this mess,” Jamie teases his nephew. “Why don’t you lead us in prayer?”
Sean grins and bows his head. “In the name of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit…”
As the family prays, the camera pans slowly around the table — faces illuminated by candlelight, each one reflecting love, loss, and the weight of legacy.
Then, as Sean says “Amen,” the screen flickers — a sudden cut to a shadowy figure watching the Reagans through a surveillance camera mounted outside the window. The same message flashes again on a nearby monitor: “Operation Hill Active.”
The music swells.

The film’s second act unravels as Joe’s dual identity begins to strain the fragile peace he’s found. Danny senses something off, tailing him after dinner one night. Erin starts digging into sealed federal files, and Jamie — torn between brotherly loyalty and police duty — demands answers.
The truth finally explodes during a tense confrontation in the commissioner’s office.
“You lied to us,” Danny snaps. “You sat at our table and kept secrets.”
Joe fires back. “I didn’t have a choice. I was protecting all of you.”
Frank slams his hand on the desk. “You don’t protect family by deceiving them, Joe. You do it by trusting them.”
But it’s too late. The operation Joe’s been part of goes south, and before dawn, bullets fly in a warehouse in Brooklyn. Joe takes a hit while saving another officer, and when Frank and Danny arrive, the scene mirrors the tragedy of Joe Reagan’s death years before.
In a heartbreaking parallel, Frank kneels beside his grandson, holding his hand as medics rush in. “Stay with me, son,” he whispers.
Joe looks up weakly. “You called me son.”
“I should’ve done that sooner,” Frank replies, eyes wet with tears.
The screen fades to white.
The final scene returns to the family dinner table weeks later. Joe’s chair is empty, but his badge rests on the plate in front of it — a silent tribute.
Jamie begins to say grace again, voice trembling. “Bless us, O Lord, and these Thy gifts…”
The camera pans over the family’s bowed heads, lingering on Frank, whose eyes drift to the empty seat.
A faint smile touches his lips. “Welcome home, Joe,” he whispers under his breath.
The screen cuts to black.
End of “Bloodline Oath.”